← Guides

In 2019 a sign reading «УКРЗОЛОТО» (UKRZOLOTO, literally «Ukrainian gold») hung over a jewellery shop in Kropyvnytskyi. The owner of the registered trademark brought two claims against the sole trader running the shop: one for an injunction and one for UAH 120,000 in damages. The damages case was stayed until the injunction case was over, so it was decided only in 2026. On 12 November 2026 the Central Commercial Court of Appeal upheld the award in full. Below we look at how the court measured lost profits and why arguments about the trademark’s purchase price and its later sale failed.

What happened

The UKRZOLOTO trademark is registered under Ukrainian certificate No. 124382 of 25 June 2010, among others for class 14 goods — jewellery. In 2019 it was acquired by Markholder LLC, whose main business is leasing intellectual property: it earns money by granting non-exclusive licences to traders.

The sole trader sold jewellery in a shop under the UKRZOLOTO sign without a licence. Markholder LLC sued in the Commercial Court of Kirovohrad Region for an injunction (case No. 912/3030/19) and, on 29 November 2019, separately for UAH 120,000 in lost profits (case No. 912/3817/19). The damages case was stayed pending the injunction case.

The injunction was granted on 6 November 2024: the trader was prohibited from using UKRZOLOTO in any font or script on signs when offering for sale and selling class 14 goods. It was upheld on appeal (7 May 2025) and by the Supreme Court (31 July 2025). The damages case resumed in January 2026, and on 29 January 2026 the court awarded UAH 120,000 in damages plus UAH 1,921 in court fees. The trader appealed; on 12 November 2026 the appeal court upheld the judgment.

UKRZOLOTO trademark, Ukrainian certificate No. 124382

Certificate No. 124382 · filed 1 February 2008, registered 25 June 2010 · renewed until 1 February 2028

How the court arrived at UAH 120,000

Article 20(2) of the Law of Ukraine on Protection of Rights to Marks for Goods and Services (the Law) obliges an infringer, at the owner’s request, to compensate the owner’s losses. Article 22(2)(2) of the Civil Code of Ukraine defines lost profits as «income that a person could actually have received in ordinary circumstances had their right not been infringed» (our translation).

The claimant showed what it earns for the same kind of use. On 10 October 2019 Markholder LLC granted another trader a non-exclusive licence to put the trademark on the sign of one jewellery shop in Odesa for one year, at a royalty of UAH 120,000 a year excluding VAT. An internal order of 1 July 2020 kept the rate unchanged. The licensee’s payment orders from 24 December 2019 to 17 August 2020 were also on file.

The appeal court relied on the Supreme Court’s resolution of 30 September 2021 in case No. 922/3928/20, under which lost profits are assessed by reference to ordinary business conditions, reasonable costs and the compensatory nature of damages. The licensed use, the court noted, was identical to the defendant’s use — a jewellery shop sign. In ordinary circumstances the defendant could have used the trademark lawfully only under a licence on those terms, and UAH 120,000 did not exceed what the claimant would have earned had the defendant acted lawfully. The defendant produced no evidence of a different rate or of absence of fault.

Infringement did not have to be proved twice. Unauthorised use of the designation on the sign had been established in the injunction case between the same parties, so under Article 75(4) of the Commercial Procedure Code of Ukraine it required no further proof.

The defence and the court’s answers

«The trademark was bought for UAH 700». The defendant relied on an agreement of 19 June 2019 under which Markholder LLC acquired the trademark for UAH 700 and argued that the royalty was 171 times its value. The court held that the purchase price reflects the bargain in a particular contract, and neither it nor the book value of the trademark shows what the owner can earn from licences. The first-instance court had also refused to admit that agreement: it existed when the defence was filed in 2020, but the defendant produced it only in 2026 without showing why he could not do so in time. The appeal court agreed that under Article 80 of the Commercial Procedure Code such evidence is inadmissible, and added that the agreement in fact confirmed rather than disproved the claimant’s title.

«The claimant no longer owns the mark». In 2021 the trademark was assigned to the closed-end venture investment fund JSC «Cefei». The court held that a later assignment does not deprive the owner of damages for infringement committed while it held the right.

«The claim is artificial». The defendant asked the court to leave the claim without consideration as manifestly unfounded. The court replied that a claim by the owner against a person who used the designation without a licence cannot be manifestly unfounded, and that sufficiency of evidence is a question of proof, not abuse of process.

The remaining grounds of appeal were procedural — recusal of the judge and the right to a reasoned judgment — and were dismissed. The resolution took effect on the day it was adopted; any further appeal is governed by Articles 286–289 of the Commercial Procedure Code. As of 19 November 2026 the Unified State Register of Court Decisions shows no later documents in the case.

What the law says now

The court applied the rules in force at the time of infringement. Since then Article 20(2) of the Law of Ukraine on Protection of Rights to Marks for Goods and Services has been amended by Law No. 2974-IX of 20 March 2023. In the current version (of 26 February 2026) the owner may claim either damages, assessed «taking into account lost profits or income received by the infringer», or statutory compensation, which «may not be lower than the fee that would have been paid for permission to use the rights to the trademark in dispute» (our translation). The choice is the owner’s.

Article 16(4) of the Law still expressly lists a sign connected with the goods for which the trademark is registered, together with offering such goods for sale and selling them, as use of a trademark.

The register today

As of 19 November 2026 certificate No. 124382 (application No. m200801717 of 1 February 2008) is in force, renewed until 1 February 2028, and owned by JSC «Cefei». This case is one of a series: the resolution mentions other UKRZOLOTO cases brought by Markholder LLC in the Commercial Court of Kirovohrad Region, including No. 912/3562/19 against another defendant, where a claim for the same UAH 120,000 was found justified. For a related dispute over a shop sign and a copyrighted logo, see our note UKRZOLOTO: a shop sign, a copyrighted logo and a trademark.

Lessons for brand owners and their counsel

  • A real licensing practice is the best evidence of lost profits. Signed licences, an approved rate and actual payments let the owner prove what it lost.
  • The purchase price of a trademark proves nothing about damages. A defendant who wants a lower figure needs evidence of a different market rate.
  • Assigning the trademark does not end the claim. The former owner may recover for the period it held the right.
  • Win the injunction first. Facts established there need not be proved again in the damages case between the same parties.
  • File evidence with the defence. A document produced six years later was not admitted.
  • Consider statutory compensation. Since 2023 the Law sets the licence fee as its minimum. See our note on assignments and licences in Ukraine.

Our view

This is our assessment, not the court’s finding. Lost profits are usually the hardest part of a trademark claim in Ukraine. Here the owner’s business model — licensing the same mark for the same kind of use at a fixed rate — turned the question into simple arithmetic. Foreign owners who license in Ukraine can build the same evidence base. The resolution does not say how courts will apply the statutory compensation regime in similar cases, since the claimant sought damages.

If your client’s trademark is used without a licence in Ukraine

We check the Ukrainian register, assess whether the designation in use is confusingly similar, and advise on a cease-and-desist letter, a licence offer or court action — including which remedy, damages or compensation, fits the evidence the owner has. Information for foreign attorneys.

Discuss an infringement in Ukraine

Send us the details — we will check the register and outline the options. Or write to office@rivnepatent.ua.

Questions we are asked about this case

How do Ukrainian courts calculate lost profits for unauthorised trademark use?

In case No. 912/3817/19 the court asked what the owner would ordinarily have earned had the infringer taken a licence. It took the rate from the owner’s licence to another trader for the same kind of use (a sign over one jewellery shop, one year): UAH 120,000 excluding VAT. The Central Commercial Court of Appeal relied on the criteria set out by the Supreme Court in its resolution of 30 September 2021 in case No. 922/3928/20: ordinary business conditions, reasonable costs and the compensatory nature of damages.

Does the price the owner paid for the trademark limit the damages?

Not in this case. The defendant argued that the owner had bought the trademark for UAH 700, so a royalty 171 times higher was unrealistic. The court held that the purchase price and the book value of the trademark as an intangible asset do not show what the owner can earn from licensing, and the defendant offered no evidence of a different rate.

Can a former owner recover damages after assigning the trademark?

Yes, for infringement committed while it owned the right. The UKRZOLOTO mark was assigned to a new owner in 2021, but the court held that a later assignment does not take away the right to damages for earlier infringement.

Does infringement have to be proved again in a separate damages case?

Not where the parties are the same. Under Article 75(4) of the Commercial Procedure Code of Ukraine, facts established by a final judgment in a case between the same parties need not be proved again. Unauthorised use on the sign had already been established in the injunction case No. 912/3030/19.

What can a trademark owner claim in Ukraine instead of damages?

Under Article 20(2) of the Law of Ukraine on Protection of Rights to Marks for Goods and Services as currently in force, the owner may choose between damages and statutory compensation. The court sets the compensation, and it cannot be lower than the fee that would have been paid for permission to use the trademark. In this case the claimant sought damages in the form of lost profits.

Sources (in Ukrainian): resolution of the Central Commercial Court of Appeal of 12 November 2026 in case No. 912/3817/19 (it summarises the judgment of the Commercial Court of Kirovohrad Region of 29 January 2026 and the judgments in case No. 912/3030/19); certificate No. 124382 in the state register as of 19 November 2026; Law of Ukraine on Protection of Rights to Marks for Goods and Services (version of 26 February 2026); Civil Code of Ukraine (version of 5 August 2026); Commercial Procedure Code of Ukraine (version of 24 April 2026). Quotations are our translation. Names of individuals are not given.

Court decisions are public documents, published in the Unified State Register of Court Decisions. This note analyses the reasoning of the decision — the arguments raised and how the court assessed them. It contains no assessment of the conduct of the parties or their representatives. Rivnepatent did not represent either party. This material is for information only and is not legal advice.

Volodymyr TarasiukAuthor: Volodymyr Tarasiuk, Ukrainian patent and trademark attorney, Reg. No. 529

See also: UKRZOLOTO: a shop sign, a copyrighted logo and a trademark · Assignments and licences in Ukraine